Ritter's Rant #109: «Дежавю» — новая европейская архитектура безопасности
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/ritters-rant-109-deja-vu-all-over
Краткое содержание
Короткий видеомонолог Риттера, названный по фразе Йоги Берры «снова дежавю». Предмет — диалог администрации Трампа и России о «новой европейской системе безопасности». Риттер напоминает, что именно это Россия предлагала 17 декабря 2021 года: проекты договоров для НАТО и для США. Тогда, по его словам, и Европа, и Вашингтон отвергли идею, заявив, что НАТО не угрожает России, а Москва выдумывает кризис; итогом стала война на Украине.
Аргумент
Спустя пять лет, считает Риттер, война — «абсолютная катастрофа»: Европа «разваливается», экономики дезинтегрируются из-за отказа от дешёвой российской энергии, НАТО не имеет реальной военной силы, а США как слабеющая держава видят в альянсе экономическую обузу. Поэтому Вашингтон ищет выход, и этим выходом становится разговор с Россией о новой архитектуре безопасности. Он ожидает, что часть гарантий безопасности Украине в постконфликтной обстановке будет привязана к этой рамке; трёхсторонние переговоры США, России и Украины, по его словам, проходят 10–11 ноября в Абу-Даби. Он утверждает, что значительная часть нынешних предложений совпадает с российскими требованиями декабря 2021 года.
Европа, по Риттеру, возражает, потому что такой диалог сорвёт с неё «налёт серьёзности»: она хочет считаться политическим союзом и военным альянсом, тогда как это «карточный домик». ЕС он описывает как недемократическое образование из назначенных элит, вмешивающееся в выборы (примеры: Румыния, давление на «Альтернативу для Германии» в Германии), где нет реального суверенитета, поскольку фокус на Брюсселе. Он считает, что Европа не может существовать без образа российской угрозы, а США больше этот нарратив не интересует.
Значимость
Монолог полемичен и содержит резкие оценки (например, о «диктатуре» ЕС и «вымирании» Украины), не подкреплённые данными. Содержательная новизна — тезис о том, что нынешний американо-российский трек во многом воспроизводит российский проект 2021 года; дальнейший ход переговоров покажет, насколько это верно.
🧾 Транскрипт (формат)
Ritter’s Rant #109 Deja Vu All Over Again
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/ritters-rant-109-deja-vu-all-over
[music]
Hello, and welcome to this edition of Ritter's Rant. Today, we're going to sort of be taking a page out of the famous baseball player, Hall of Famer Yogi Berra, who noted once that it's like deja vu all over again. We could even go further with another American saying, if at first you don't succeed, try, try again. Now, what am I talking about here? I'm talking about, you know, the current dialogue that is taking place between Washington, D.C., the Trump administration and Russia over what is being called a new European security framework. Now, you know, this is a conversation that hasn't been bandied about lately in the diplomatic discourse between either Washington, D.C. or Russia or Europe and Russia. But. Those who have a memory, and you don't have to have the memory of an elephant here, we don't have to go back that far, just to say December 17th, 2021, about five years ago, would recall that Russia, in order to prevent an escalation of tensions between the West and Russia over Ukraine, in order to prevent a war, Russia proposed that The collective West, the United States and Europe, sit down with Russia and have a dialogue about a new European security framework.
There it is, deja vu all over again. The Russians even put forward a draft treaty. They ginned one up for NATO, turned it over to the Europeans, and they ginned one up for the United States, turned it over to Washington, D.C., and both Europe and the United States turned their nose up at it. They said it's just It's ridiculous. There's no need for a new European security framework. NATO and the United States do not pose a threat to Russia at all. And they dismissed it. They accused the Russians of, you know, inventing a crisis and promoting a solution that was more about promoting Russian interests than it was about preserving NATO and American interests. And... The end result was the war with Ukraine. And here we are more than five years later. The war is an absolute disaster. Europe is falling apart, literally collapsing in on itself. We have riots in the streets. We have economies that are just literally disintegrating before our very eyes.
And the United States itself has found itself alienated from Europe and Viewing NATO as nothing more than an economic drag on it. NATO has no real military power, and the United States is a declining power globally. And so now the question is, how does the United States extricate itself from the problems that have manifested because of the conflict in Ukraine? And the answer is apparently to have, believe it or not, a dialogue with Russia about a new European security framework agreement. Now, Europe, of course, is up in arms. This is not the conversation they want because to do so would strip away the veneer of seriousness that Europe has tried to code itself in. They want to be seen as a serious political union. They want to be seen as a serious military alliance. They want to be seen as global leaders economically, militarily, politically. It's just a facade. You know, this isn't a solid foundation of brick and stone.
This is a house of cards, Europe. And the first strong wind in the house of cards will collapse and it's collapsing as we speak. The United States, likewise, you know, would You know, approach the issue of a new European security framework is an abandonment of its allies, abandonment of commitments, abandonment of principles. But today, where have those allies committed principles gotten us involved neck deep in a war that is going badly, a war that's leading to the extinction of the nation Ukraine that we ostensibly were rallying in support of and the exposure of the reality that the values that we were embracing, European values, don't exist. What does Europe stand for today? What does the European Union stand for? It certainly isn't democracy. There is no democratic processes taking place in the European leadership. These are handpicked political and economic elites who are accountable to no one and get to make statements that impact everybody.
Do they believe in democratic values? I don't know. Ask the Romanians how they feel about that. Ask You know, Germany, how they feel about the Alternative for Deutschland Party threatening to be kicked out for having the sin of making more sense to a majority of Germans than any other party. The European Union interferes in democracy, doesn't promote democracy. The European Union is a dictatorship that's trying to dictate solutions to sovereign nations. But there is no such thing as a sovereign nation in the European Union. They've created this artificial entity that The focus is on Brussels, not the capitals of the various nations. The economies are collapsing because of the ridiculous decision made to sanction Russia and to cut Europe off from the one thing that made Europe economically viable, which was cheap Russian energy. And the United States is in a difficult position because now we're being asked to shoulder the burden of Europe's failures, and we're not willing to do that.
We recognize that peace and coexistence, people's coexistence with Russia is... There's a better course of action than continued isolation, sanctioning, and violence. We don't want war with Russia. We want the war to end. And Europe, of course, in its current configuration, is incapable of existing without a war in Russia. They built all their hope and aspirations on the notion that Russia a threat worthy of military confrontation. The United States isn't interested in that particular narrative anymore. And so The dialogue begins, and we're going to see that November 10th and 11th in Abu Dhabi when the United States sits down, trilateral talks with Russia and Ukraine. Part of the security guarantees that will be offered to Ukraine in a post-conflict environment will be guarantees attached to a new European security framework. But is it really new? Because when you look at the details of it, Much of what's being put on the table is exactly what Russia had put on the table back in December of 2021.
It's deja vu all over again, ladies and gentlemen. And if at first you don't succeed, try, try again. Anyways, that's my rant. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know.
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ ═══ Транскрипция видео ═══ ════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
═══ Транскрипция видео 1 ═══
Hello and welcome to this edition of Ritter's Rant. Today we're going to sort of be taking a page out of the famous baseball player, Hall of Famer Yogi Berra, who noted once that it's like deja vu all over again. We could even go further with another American saying, if at first you don't succeed, try, try again. Now, what am I talking about here? I'm talking about, you know, the current dialogue that is taking place between Washington, D.C., the Trump administration and Russia over what is being called a new European security framework. Now, you know, this is a conversation that hasn't been bandied about lately in the diplomatic discourse between either Washington, D.C. or Russia or Europe and Russia. But those who have a memory and you don't have to have the memory of an elephant here, we don't have to go back that far. Just to say December 17th, 2021, about five years ago, would recall that Russia, in order to prevent an escalation of tensions between the West and Russia over Ukraine in order to prevent a war, Russia proposed that the collective West, the United States and Europe sit down with Russia and have a dialogue about a new European security framework. There it is. Deja vu all over again. The Russians even put forward a draft treaty. They ginned one up for NATO, turned it over to the Europeans, and they ginned one up for the United States, turned it over to Washington, D.C. And both Europe and the United States turned their nose up at it. They said it's just, it's ridiculous. There's no need for a new European security framework.
NATO and the United States do not pose a threat to Russia at all. And they dismissed it. They'd accused the Russians of, you know, inventing a crisis and promoting a solution that was more about promoting Russian interests than it was about preserving NATO and American interests. And the end result was the war with Ukraine. And here we are, more than five years later. The war is an absolute disaster. Europe is falling apart, literally collapsing in on itself. We have riots in the streets. We have economies that are just literally disintegrating before our very eyes. And the United States itself has found itself alienated from Europe, viewing NATO as nothing more than an economic drag on it. NATO has no real military power. And the United States is a declining power globally. And so now the question is, how does the United States extricate itself from the problems that have manifested because of the conflict in Ukraine? And the answer is apparently to have, believe it or not, a dialogue with Russia about a new European security framework agreement. Now, Europe, of course, is up in arms. This is not the conversation they want because to do so would strip away, you know, the veneer of, you know, seriousness that Europe has tried to code itself in. They want to be seen as a serious political union. They want to be seen as a serious military alliance. They want to be seen as global leaders economically, militarily, politically. But it's just a facade. You know, this isn't a, you know, a solid foundation of brick and stone. This is a house of cards, Europe. And the first strong wind in the house of cards will collapse.
And it's collapsing as we speak. The United States, likewise, you know, would, you know, approach the issue of a new European security framework as an abandonment of its allies, abandonment of commitments, abandonment of principles. But today, where have those allies' commitment principles gotten us? Involved neck deep in a war that is going badly, a war that's leading to the extinction of the nation, Ukraine, that we ostensibly were rallying in support of, and the exposure of the reality that the values that we were embracing, European values, don't exist. What does Europe stand for today? What does the European Union stand for? Where it certainly isn't democracy. There is no democratic processes taking place in the European leadership. These are handpicked political and economic elites who are accountable to no one and get to make statements that impact everybody. Do they believe in democratic values?
I don't know. Ask the Romanians how they feel about that. Ask, you know, Germany how they feel about the alternative for Deutschland party threatening to be kicked out for having the sin of making more sense to a majority of Germans than any other party. The European Union interferes in democracy, doesn't promote democracy. The European Union is a dictatorship that's trying to dictate solutions to sovereign nations. But there is no such thing as a sovereign nation in the European Union. They've created this artificial entity that focuses on Brussels, not the capitals of the various nations. The economies are collapsing because of the ridiculous decision made to sanction Russia and to cut Europe off from the one thing that made Europe economically viable, which was cheap Russian energy. You know, and the United States is in a difficult position because now we're being asked to shoulder the burden of Europe's failures. And we're not willing to do that. We recognize that peace and coexistence, people coexistence with Russia is a better course of action than continued, you know, isolation, sanctioning and violence. We don't want war with Russia. We want the war to end.
And Europe, of course, in its current configuration, is incapable of existing without a war in Russia. They built all their hope and aspirations on the notion that Russia is a threat worthy of military confrontation. The United States isn't interested in that particular narrative anymore. And so the dialogue begins. And we're going to see that November 10th and 11th in Abu Dhabi when the United States sits down, trilateral talks with Russia and Ukraine. Part of the security guarantees that will be offered to Ukraine in a post-conflict environment will be guarantees attached to a new European security framework. But is it really new? Because when you look at the details of it, much of what's being put on the table is exactly what Russia had put on the table back in December of 2021. It's deja vu all over again, ladies and gentlemen. And if at first you don't succeed, try, try again. Anyways, that's my rant. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. Next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know.