Ritter's Rant #108: «Миф об Олешках» — Риттер о гуманитарной операции и украинской «мифологии»
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/ritters-rant-108-the-oleshky-myth
Краткое содержание
Видеомонолог Риттера сразу после завершения гуманитарной операции в Олешках (Херсонская область). Он утверждает, что украинская сторона выстроила вокруг города «миф» о российской блокаде и голоде, тогда как гуманитарную катастрофу, по его версии, создала и поддерживала сама Украина, а целью операции была не помощь людям, а пропагандистский прецедент и «перемирие ради передышки». Позиции Риттера односторонни и противоречат украинским и значительной части независимых свидетельств; ниже изложена его логика.
Положение города
Олешки — город, где раньше жили около 24 тысяч человек, находится на левом берегу Днепра напротив украинских позиций на правом берегу, которые, как говорит Риттер, имеют преимущество по высоте и используют его для артиллерийского огня и ударов дронов по жителям и российским военным. Около 20 тысяч человек ушли, «в основном в Россию, потому что считают себя русскими»; около 4 тысяч остались — они и стали адресатами помощи. Украина и Запад видят Херсонщину оккупированной территорией, но, по Риттеру, это «семантика» после референдума сентября 2022 года (легитимность референдума не признана ООН и большинством государств).
Жизнь в городе осложнили, говорит он, подрыв дамбы выше по течению (он приписывает его украинскому правительству; публично ответственность за разрушение Каховской ГЭС оспаривается сторонами) и решение Украины после весны этого года изолировать город и «терроризировать население»: перекрыть оба подъездных пути артиллерией и повторными ударами дронов, атаковать российские гуманитарные конвои. Довод: России нет смысла обстреливать город, который она и так контролирует. Во время перемирия, по его словам, россияне выложили на показ украинские дроны с серийными номерами (FP-1, FP-2, Hornet, FPV, «Баба-яга»), которыми совершались атаки.
«Невинное население» и партизаны
Риттер указывает на карту Института изучения войны, на которой Олешки помечены как зона «значительной активности украинских партизан», и называет ISW прозападной «пропагандистской» организацией семьи Каганов. Украина, по его утверждению, сбрасывала с тяжёлых дронов «Баба-яга» еду и снабжение, но это, говорит он, были миссии по снабжению партизан: российские силы, не желая допускать непроверенные грузы, изымали их, при этом еду распределяли среди жителей; внутри были также средства связи для сбора разведданных о российских войсках, по которым затем наводились артиллерия и дроны. «Идея невинного украинского населения в Олешках — абсолютная шутка», хотя невиновные там были. Украинская разведка, координирующая партизан, постоянно комментирует ситуацию, потому что у неё там интерес.
Политика перемирия
По Риттеру, Украина превратила кризис в политический, чтобы добиться перемирия по линии фронта: Россия отказывается от него без «комплексного мирного плана», которого нет, потому что Зеленский его не хочет. Передышка нужна ВСУ для ротации и переоснащения. Олешки — «операция, порождающая перемирие», задуманная как первый прецедент для повторения. Россия, замечает он, не афишировала число эвакуированных и их направление, не политизируя помощь.
Яне Лантратовой Риттер отдаёт «огромный кредит» (с мая-июня она занималась проблемой). Её украинский коллега Дмитрий Лубинец, по его оценке, начинал как гуманист, но затем перешёл к пропаганде: например, когда кадры британского Sky News показали ротацию российских позиций под прикрытием гуманитарной операции, Лубинец заявил, что машины с красными крестами занимались разминированием по согласованию с украинской стороной. Риттер считает это ложью. Роль Мелании Трамп он характеризует как политическое «прикрытие сверху», а тяжёлую работу приписывает двум омбудсменам и предлагает номинировать обоих на Нобелевскую премию мира, хотя правительство Украины, по его мнению, не серьёзно относится к гуманитарному вмешательству.
Значимость
Монолог — пример конкурирующих нарративов вокруг первого локального перемирия в Олешках: российская версия (катастрофа создана Киевом, партизаны как законная цель) против украинской (блокада и голод по вине России). Независимой проверки в тексте нет; выводы Риттера (включая недоверие к независимым СМИ вроде Sky News) стоит сопоставлять с данными международных организаций.
🧾 Транскрипт (формат)
Ritter’s Rant #108: The Oleshky Myth
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/ritters-rant-108-the-oleshky-myth
[music]
Hello and welcome to this edition of Ritter's Rant. Today we're going to be taking a journey down the path of mythology, the Aleshky myth, as told by the Ukrainian myth makers. Aleshky, of course, is a town, a city, formerly of around 24,000 people, located in the Kherson Oblast. Kherson was a territory that had been occupied by Russia after the initiation of the special military operation in February of 2022. Then following a referendum that was held in September of 2022, where the population voted to become part of the Russian Federation, the Kherson Oblast was incorporated into the Russian Federation. And this is an important part of the... of the narrative shaping taking place by the Ukrainians about this city, its inhabitants, and what's been happening. We just saw a successful humanitarian operation, you know, being implemented in and around the city of Aleshky. Yes, there used to be 24,000 people living there, but Aleshky is right next to the Dnieper River, and it's literally On the front lines of the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
Ukrainian forces are on the right side of the right bank of the of the of the Nipper River. They have an advantage in height and they've used that advantage to terrain artillery fire and to direct drone attacks on the citizens and Russian soldiers living and operating in and around the inverns of the city. As a result, Around 20,000 people have left, the vast majority of whom went to Russia because they're Russian. They consider themselves to be Russian. They are Russian constitutionally from a Russian standpoint. Yes, the Ukrainian government and their Western supporters continue to view Kirson as occupied territory. But this is semantics. The reality is the people who live on the ground view themselves as Russian predominantly. There are some holdovers. There are exceptions, of course. And this, I guess, was the heart of the humanitarian effort to go into Eleski and provide humanitarian relief for the approximately 4,000 civilians that were left behind who opted to stay or who couldn't leave because of the difficult conditions that existed.
We'll get to that in a minute. You know, it's been a difficult time for the citizens of Eleshky. As I said, they're on the front line. Life was made even harder when the Ukrainian government, by the way, not the Russians, the Ukrainian government blew a dam further north that said flooding down. Significant harm was done to the city and to, you know, into its economy and to, you know, just the ability to live life. The dam did a whole bunch of damage to Eleshky. That's one of the reasons why life became hard. The other reason is that The Ukrainians, rather than just simply viewing the Dnieper River as a barrier, decided to take political advantage of the proximity of Eleshky to Ukrainian forces. And they, especially after the spring of this year, made a decision to isolate Eleshky, to terrorize the population. They, of course, blamed it on the Russians. They said that the Russians are the ones who are subjecting the citizens to drone attacks, shelling them with artillery.
But this makes no sense since Zelensky is within the Russian zone of operations and, you know, Russian troops don't need to shell a city they already occupy. They don't need to, you know, carry out drone attacks against the city they already occupy. The narrative fell apart, but this became part of the myth-making that was taking place. Russia was punishing these people. Russia was starving these people to death. Now, I'm not saying these people were not suffering. Of course they were. When the Ukrainian government made a decision to shut down Both roads that lead into Oleski, there's only two that lead in, shut them both down with artillery and drone attack, repeated drone attacks. The people started to go hungry. Russia tried to organize humanitarian convoys and indeed worked through appropriate channels to try and get clearance for these convoys going in. It's the Ukrainians who attacked these convoys repeatedly.
And look, there's just no question who did the drones. Well, during the ceasefire, the... The Russians laid out the drones. They're all Ukrainian drones. You know, ones that we recognize, the FP2s, the FP1s, the Hornets are there. And then all the various varieties of FPV drones, including the Baba Yagas and the smaller attack drones. They're all laid out for the world to see. Serial numbers, everything. They all belong. To the Ukrainians, who carried out these attacks. But the narrative-making, the myth-making was, no, it was the Russians doing this. It wasn't the Russians doing this. Another interesting thing about Eleshki is the notion of an innocent civilian population. The Institute for the Study of War, a very pro-Ukrainian, pro-war organization, They claim to be nonpartisan, but it's run by the Kagan family. So we know they're warmongers who promote an anti-Russian agenda. When they put forward a map showing the Eleski area, they color-coded the city in a sort of And when you look at the key, it says areas of significant Ukrainian partisan activity.
And this is important because, you know, what I'm going to talk about next, it puts it into relevance. The Ukrainians claim that the. The Russians prevented them from providing food to the population of Oleski. The Ukrainians say, we brought in the Baba Yagas, the big eight armed, you know, Okko drones to drop food and supplies off to these people. It's also called a resupply mission for partisans, which is exactly what it was. And of course, the Russians didn't want this stuff coming in uninspected. So whenever a Baba Yaga showed up, the Russians would go and seize the material. And more often than not, yes, some of it was food, which the Russians would then seek to distribute to the total population. There were other things, communication devices, et cetera, because these partisans were actively engaged in collecting intelligence about Russian troops that would then provide to the Ukrainians so they could attack the Russian troops with artillery and drones.
That's what partisans do. And so the idea of an innocent Ukrainian population residing in Oleski is just an absolute joke. I'm not saying... That there weren't innocents there, but the Ukrainian government weaponized it, and they acknowledged this in their press statements. You know, an organization that belongs to Ukrainian intelligence that's responsible for coordinating partisan activities is constantly commenting about the situation in Oleski because they have a vested interest. It's their partisans operating there. Now, the Russians, the Ukrainians decided to make this a big deal. And they did that by creating. This is a man-made event. The humanitarian disaster is a man-made event, totally manufactured by the Ukrainians. Then they made it a deal that the Russians were... Making this happen weren't helping them solve the problem. So it took on a political context. And, you know, since May, June of this year, the Russian ombudsman for human rights, Yana Lantratova, has been focused on helping the people of Russia.
Now, her goal has been to do a legitimate humanitarian operation. The Ukrainian goal has always been to create a propaganda exercise, to demonize the Russians and to do what they couldn't do otherwise. The Ukrainians have been calling for a ceasefire in the area. The ceasefire all along the front line, which Russians won't do. The Russians say you're not getting a ceasefire without a comprehensive peace plan. There is no comprehensive policeman because Zelensky doesn't want a peace plan. But a ceasefire buys time for the Ukrainians to arrest their troops, rotate their troops, re-equip their troops, etc. So they're trying to create conditions for ceasefires. Alekshki is a ceasefire generating operation. It's supposed to be the initial example. Um, you know, sort of the, uh, the precedent that would be set for additional things. And you hear today, even when Oleski is done, now that Ukraine is saying, this is something we seek to repeat over and over and over again, because this was a good deal for them.
Um, Notice that the Russians are downplaying issues like how many people were evacuated, who went to Ukraine, who went to Russia. Why? Because the Russians aren't seeking to politicize a humanitarian relief operation. Their objective was to bring assistance to the people that needed assistance, regardless of where their loyalties were. And Yana Lantratova deserves a tremendous amount of credit for this. So does her counterpart, Dmitry Lubinitz. He's the Ukrainian ombudsman for human rights. And, you know, I think they both developed a good reputation over time. But the difference is that he has gone back. Instead of promoting humanitarianism, he's promoting pro-Ukrainian propaganda. He's allowing, you know. The events to be shifted in a way that, you know, accuses the Russians of nefarious activity. For instance, one of the big things taking place today is that the Russians used the humanitarian relief operation to reinforce their positions, to rotate their positions.
And the evidence brought forward is videoed from Sky News, a British outlet, which is very anti-Russian, saying this is what we filmed during this. You know, Dmitry Lubinets came out and said, now, you see, we actually coordinated this with the Russians and these vehicles were painted with red crosses. They are involved in demining operations. We've monitored this activity closely. Once they finish their demining work, they return to their original posture. So they're lying. The Ukrainians lie. The pro-Ukrainian media lies. They spin this in a dozen different ways. But what they're not doing is telling the truth. If they were telling the truth, they would admit up front that Aleshky was a Ukrainian propaganda exercise from day one, that the humanitarian disaster that existed in Aleshky, no one's denying this, was perpetrated by the Ukrainians. It was Ukrainian drones that isolated the city.
The Russians simply did not attack Oleski because Oleski belongs to Russia. But this is the myth-making that's taking place. And it's important that... You know, we understand this because this Oleski precedent is something that people are going to be promoting going forward. Melania Trump has attached her name to this effort. You know, she did provide political support. You know, cover overhead, but the hard, the heavy lifting was done by Jana Lantratova and Dmitry Lubinitz. These two people deserve all the credit in the world. Indeed, you know, in this day and age when we're looking for heroes, when we're looking for people to label peacemakers and, you know, peacekeepers, people promoting peace, people may be deservant of a Nobel Peace Prize. These two names should be front and center. Yana Latratova of the Russian Federation, Dmitry Lubinitz of Ukraine. These are people who worked hard.
The Russian government, I believe, is very sincere in promoting genuine humanitarianism. Dmitry, I believe, is likewise, but his government, as we've seen, is not serious about humanitarian intervention. They're serious about... Creating a humanitarian crisis and using that to promote an anti-Russian agenda. But this doesn't detract from the hard work that Dmitry Lubinitz did together with Jana Lantrava. So when we think about the Nobel Peace Prize, when we think about people deserving of this, I would suggest that people start talking about these two people. Jana Lantrava, Dmitry Lubinitz. These should be the future Nobel Peace Prize winners for what they did in Oleski and hopefully what they can do down the road in, you know, alleviating the humanitarian consequences of war. Anyways, this is my rant. The next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know.
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ ═══ Транскрипция видео ═══ ════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
═══ Транскрипция видео 1 ═══
Hello and welcome to this edition of Ritter's Rant. Today we're going to be taking a journey down the path of mythology, the Ileszky myth, as told by the Ukrainian myth makers. Ileszky, of course, is a town, a city, formerly of around 24,000 people, located in the Kherson Oblast. Kherson was a territory that had been occupied by Russia after the initiation of the special military operation in February of 2022. Then following a referendum that was held in September of 2022, where the population voted to become part of the Russian Federation, the Kherson Oblast was incorporated into the Russian Federation. And this is an important part of the narrative shaping taking place by the Ukrainians about this city, its inhabitants, and what's been happening. We just saw a successful humanitarian operation, you know, being implemented in and around the city of Ileszky. Yes, there were used to be 24,000 people living there, but Ileszky is right next to the Dnieper River. And it's literally on the front lines of the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Ukrainian forces are on the right side of the right bank of the Dnieper River. They have an advantage in height, and they've used that advantage to terrain artillery fire and to direct drone attacks on the citizens and Russian soldiers living and operating in and around the inverns of the city. As a result, around 20,000 people have left, the vast majority of whom went to Russia because they're Russian. They consider themselves to be Russian. They are Russian constitutionally from a Russian standpoint. Yes, the Ukrainian government and their Western supporters continue to view Kherson as occupied territory, but this is semantics. The reality is the people who live on the ground view themselves as Russian predominantly. There are some holdovers. There are exceptions, of course. And this, I guess, was the heart of the humanitarian effort to go into Ileszky and provide humanitarian relief for the approximately 4,000 civilians that were left behind who opted to stay or who couldn't leave because of the difficult conditions that existed.
We'll get to that in a minute. You know, it's been a difficult time for the citizens of Ileszky. As I said, they're on the front line. Life was made even harder when the Ukrainian government, by the way, not the Russians, the Ukrainian government, blew a dam further north that said flooding down. Significant harm was done to the city and to, you know, into its economy and to, you know, just the ability to live life. The dam did a whole bunch of damage to Ileszky. That's one of the reasons why life became hard. The other reason is that the Ukrainians, rather than just simply viewing the Dnieper River as a barrier, you know, decided to take political advantage of the proximity of Ileszky to Ukrainian forces. And they, especially after, you know, the spring of this year, made a decision to isolate Ileszky, to terrorize the population. Now, they, of course, blamed it on the Russians. They said that the Russians are the ones who are subjecting the citizens to drone attacks, shelling them with artillery. But this makes no sense since Ileszky is within the Russian zone of operations. And, you know, Russian troops don't need to shell the city. They already occupy. They don't need to, you know, carry out drone attacks against the city. They already occupy. The narrative fell apart, but this became part of the myth-making that was taking place. Russia was punishing these people. Russia was starving these people to death. Now, I'm not saying these people were not suffering. Of course they were. When the Ukrainian government made a decision to shut down both roads that lead into Ileszky, there's only two that lead in, shut them both down with artillery and drone attack, repeated drone attacks, the people started to go hungry. Russia tried to organize humanitarian convoys and, indeed, worked, you know, through appropriate channels to try and get clearance for these convoys going in. It's the Ukrainians who attacked these convoys repeatedly with drones, killing people and preventing food and medicine and everything going in. The hospital, the Leszky hospital, whenever an ambulance tried to take somebody out to a, you know, a regional hospital, it was attacked by drones. And, look, there's just no question who did the drones. Well, you know, during the ceasefire, the Russians laid out the drones. They're all Ukrainian drones. You know, ones that we recognize, the FP-2s, the FP-1s, the Hornets are there. And then all the various varieties of FPV drones, including the Baba Yagas and the smaller attack drones. They're all laid out for the world to see. Serial numbers, everything. They all belong to the Ukrainians who carried out these attacks. But the narrative-making, the myth-making was, no, it was the Russians doing this. It wasn't the Russians doing this. The, another interesting thing about Leszky is the notion of an innocent civilian population.
The Institute for the Study of War, a very pro-Ukrainian, pro-war, they claim to be nonpartisan, but it's run by the Kagan family. So we, we know they're warmongers who promote an anti-Russian agenda. When they put forward a map showing the Leszky area, they, they color-coded the city in a, in sort of red with a blue checkered overlay. And when you look at the key, it says, areas of significant Ukrainian partisan activity. And this is important because, you know, what I'm going to talk about next, it puts it into relevance. The Ukrainians claim that the, the Russians prevented them from providing food to the population of Leszky. The Ukrainians say, we brought in the Baba Yagas, the big eight-armed, you know, Octo, the drones to drop food and supplies off to these people. It's also called a resupply mission for partisans, which is exactly what it was. And of course, the Russians, you know, didn't want this stuff coming in uninspected. So whenever a Baba Yagas showed up, the Russians would go and seize the, the, the material. And, you know, more often than not, yes, some of it was food, which the Russians would then seek to distribute to the total population. But there were other things, communication devices, et cetera, because these partisans were actively engaged in collecting intelligence. about Russian troops that would then provide to the Ukrainians so they could attack the Russian troops with artillery and drones. That's what partisans do. And so the, the idea of an innocent Ukrainian population residing in Leszky is just an absolute joke. I'm not saying that there weren't innocents there, but the, the Ukrainian government weaponized, and they acknowledge this in their press statements, you know, an organization that belongs to Ukrainian intelligence that's responsible for coordinating partisan activities is constantly commenting about the situation in Leszky because they have a vested interest. the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the, the humanitarian disaster is a man-made event, totally manufactured by the Ukrainians. Then they made it a deal that the Russians were making this happen, weren't helping them solve the problem. So it took on a political context and, you know, since May, June of this year, the, the Russian ombudsman for human rights, Yana Lantratova, has been focused on helping the people of Leszky. Now her goal has been to do a legitimate humanitarian operation. The Ukrainian goal has always been to create a propaganda exercise to demonize the Russians and to do what they couldn't do otherwise. The Ukrainians have been calling for a ceasefire, uh, in the, um, you know, in the area and the, uh, you know, ceasefire all along the front line, which Russians won't do. The Russians say you're not getting a ceasefire without a comprehensive peace plan. There is no comprehensive policeman because Zelensky doesn't want a peace plan, but a ceasefire buys time for the Ukrainians to, you know, arrest their troops, rotate their troops, re-equip their troops, et cetera. So they're trying to create conditions for ceasefires. Zelensky is a ceasefire generating operation. It's supposed to be, uh, the, the initial, uh, example, um, you know, sort of the, uh, the precedent that would be set for additional thing. And you hear today, even when the Leszky is done, now that you can say, this is something we seek to repeat over and over and over again, because this was a good deal for them. Um, you notice that the Russians are downplaying issues like how many people were evacuated, who went to Ukraine, who went to Russia. Why? Because the Russians aren't seeking to politicize a humanitarian relief operation. Their objective was to bring assistance to the people that needed assistance, regardless of where their loyalties were. Um, and Yana Lantratova deserves a tremendous amount of credit for this. So does her, her, uh, counterpart, uh, Dmitry Lubinitz. He's a, uh, the, the Ukrainian ombudsman for human rights. And, you know, I, I think they both developed a good reputation over time, but the difference is that he has gone back and instead of promoting humanitarianism, he's promoting pro-Ukrainian propaganda. And he's allowing, you know, um, the, the, the events to be shifted in a way that, you know, accuses the Russians of nefarious activity. For instance, one of the big things taking place today is that, uh, the Russians used the humanitarian relief operation to reinforce their positions, to rotate their positions. And the evidence brought forward is video from Sky News, a British outlet, which is very anti-Russian, uh, saying, this is what we filmed during this. Uh, but, you know, Dmitry Lubinitz came out and said, now you see, we actually coordinated this with the Russians. And, uh, these vehicles were painted with red crosses. They are involved in demining operations. We've monitored this activity closely. Once they finished their demining work, they returned to their original posture. So they're, they're lying. The Ukrainians lie. Um, the pro-Ukrainian media lies.
They spin this in, uh, you know, a dozen different ways, but what they're not doing is telling the truth. If they were telling the truth, they would admit upfront that Oleski was Ukrainian propaganda exercise from day one. That the humanitarian disaster that existed in Oleski, no one's denying this, was perpetrated by the Ukrainians. It was Ukrainian drones that isolated the city, denied food from being brought in. It was Ukrainian drones that terrorized the civilian population. It was Ukrainian artillery that did the same thing. Whenever the Russians tried to send in humanitarian relief, the Ukrainians attacked them. The Russians simply did not attack Oleski because Oleski belongs to Russia. But this is the myth-making that's taking place. Um, and it's important that, you know, we understand this, uh, because this Oleski precedent is something that people are going to be promoting going forward. Melania Trump has attached her name to this effort. Um, um, you know, she, she did provide political, um, you know, cover overhead, but the hard, the heavy lifting was done by Yana Latvatova and Dmitry Lubinitz. These two people deserve all the credit world. Indeed, you know, in this day and age, when we're looking for heroes, when we're looking for people to, um, to label peacemakers and, you know, peacekeepers, uh, people promoting peace, people may be deserving of a Nobel peace prize. These two names should be front and center. Yana Latvatova of the Russian Federation, Dmitry Lubinitz of the Ukraine, uh, of Ukraine. These are people who worked hard. The Russian government, I believe is very sincere in promoting, um, you know, genuine humanitarianism. Um, Dmitry, I believe is likewise, but his government, as we've seen is, uh, is not serious about humanitarian intervention. They're serious about, um, creating a humanitarian crisis and using that to promote an anti-Russian agenda. Um, but this doesn't detract from the hard work that Dmitry Lubinitz did together with Yana Latvatova. So when we, when we think about the Nobel peace prize, when we think about people deserving of this, um, I would, you know, suggest that people start talking about these two people. Yana Latvatova, Dmitry Lubinitz, these should be the future Nobel peace prize winners for what they did in Oleski and hopefully what they can do down the road and, you know, alleviating the humanitarian consequences of war. Anyways, this is, uh, my rant. My rant, the next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. you Thank you.
═══ Транскрипция видео 2 ═══
Hello and welcome to this edition of Ritter's Rant. Today we're going to be taking a journey down the path of mythology, the Eleshky myth, as told by the Ukrainian myth makers. Eleshky, of course, is a town, a city, formerly of around 24,000 people, located in the Kherson oblast. Kherson was a territory that had been occupied by Russia after the initiation of the special military operation in February of 2022. Then following a referendum that was held in September of 2022, where the population voted to become part of the Russian Federation, the Kherson oblast was incorporated into the Russian Federation. And this is an important part of the of the narrative shaping taking place by the Ukrainians about this city, its inhabitants and what's been happening. We just saw a successful humanitarian operation being implemented in and around the city of Eleshky. Yes, there were used to be 24,000 people living there. But Eleshky is right next to the Dnieper River, and it's literally on the front lines of the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Ukrainian forces are on the right side of the right bank of the Dnieper River. They have an advantage in height, and they've used that advantage to terrain artillery fire and to direct drone attacks on the citizens and Russian soldiers living and operating in and around the inverns of the city. As a result, around 20,000 people have left, the vast majority of whom went to Russia because they're Russian. They consider themselves to be Russian. They are Russian constitutionally from a Russian standpoint. Yes, the Ukrainian government and their Western supporters continue to view Kherson as occupied territory. But this is semantics. The reality is the people who live on the ground view themselves as Russian predominantly. There are some holdovers. There are exceptions, of course. And this, I guess, was the heart of the humanitarian effort to go into Eleshky and provide humanitarian relief for the approximately 4,000 civilians that were left behind who opted to stay or who couldn't leave because of the difficult conditions that existed.
We'll get to that in a minute. You know, it's been a difficult time for the citizens of Eleshky. As I said, they're on the front line. Life was made even harder when the Ukrainian government, by the way, not the Russians, the Ukrainian government, blew a dam further north. It said flooding down. Significant harm was done to the city and to, you know, into its economy and to, you know, just the ability to live life. The dam did a whole bunch of damage to Eleshky. That's one of the reasons why life became hard. The other reason is that the Ukrainians, rather than just simply viewing the Dnieper River as a barrier, you know, decided to take political advantage of the proximity of Eleshky to Ukrainian forces. And they, especially after, you know, the spring of this year, made a decision to isolate Eleshky, to terrorize the population. Now, they, of course, blamed it on the Russians. They said that the Russians are the ones who are subjecting the citizens to drone attacks, shelling them with artillery. But this makes no sense, since Eleshky is within the Russian zone of operations, and, you know, Russian troops don't need to shell a city they already occupy. They don't need to, you know, carry out drone attacks against the city they already occupy. The narrative fell apart, but this became part of the myth-making that was taking place. Russia was punishing these people. Russia was starving these people to death. Now, I'm not saying these people were not suffering. Of course they were. When the Ukrainian government made a decision to shut down both roads that lead into Eleshky, there's only two that lead in, shut them both down with artillery and drone attack, repeated drone attacks, the people started to go hungry. Russia tried to organize humanitarian convoys and, indeed, worked, you know, through appropriate channels to try and get clearance for these convoys going in. It's the Ukrainians who attacked these convoys repeatedly with drones, killing people and preventing food and medicine and everything going in. Hospital, the Eleshky hospital, whenever an ambulance tried to take somebody out to a, you know, a regional hospital, it was attacked by drones. And, look, there's just no question who did the drones while, you know, during the ceasefire, the Russians laid out the drones. They're all Ukrainian drones. You know, ones that we recognize, the FP-2s, the FP-1s, the Hornets are there. And then all the various varieties of FPV drones, including the Baba Yagas and the smaller attack drones, they're all laid out for the world to see, serial numbers, everything. They all belong to the Ukrainians who carried out these attacks. But the narrative-making, the myth-making was, no, it was the Russians doing this. It wasn't the Russians doing this. Another interesting thing about Eleshky is the notion of an innocent civilian population. The Institute for the Study of War, a very pro-Ukrainian, pro-war, they claim to be nonpartisan, but it's run by the Kagan family. So we know they're warmongers who promote an anti-Russian agenda. When they put forward a map showing the Eleshky area, they color-coded the city in sort of red with a blue checkered overlay.
And when you look at the key, it says, areas of significant Ukrainian partisan activity. And this is important because, you know, what I'm going to talk about next, it puts it into relevance. The Ukrainians claim that the Russians prevented them from providing food to the population of Eleshky. The Ukrainians say, we brought in the Baba Yagas, the big eight-armed, you know, Octo drones to drop food and supplies off to these people. It's also called a resupply mission for partisans, which is exactly what it was. And, of course, the Russians, you know, didn't want this stuff coming in uninspected. So whenever a Baba Yaga showed up, the Russians would go and seize the material. And, you know, more often than not, yes, some of it was food, which the Russians would then seek to distribute to the total population. But there were other things, communication devices, et cetera, because these partisans were actively engaged in collecting intelligence about Russian troops that would then provide to the Ukrainians so they could attack the Russian troops with artillery and drones. And so the idea of an innocent Ukrainian population residing in Eleshky is just an absolute joke. I'm not saying that there weren't innocents there, but the Ukrainian government weaponized, and they acknowledged this in their press statements, you know, an organization that belongs to Ukrainian intelligence that's responsible for coordinating partisan activities, constantly commenting about the situation in Eleshky because they have a vested interest. It's their partisans operating there now, but once the Russians, the Ukrainians decided to make this a big deal, and they did that by creating this is a manmade event. The humanitarian disaster is a manmade event, totally manufactured by the Ukrainians. Then they made it a deal that the Russians were making this happen, weren't helping them solve the problem. So it took on a political context. And, you know, since May, June of this year, the Russian ombudsman for human rights, Yana Lantratova, has been focused on helping the people of Eleshky. Now, her goal has been to do a legitimate humanitarian operation. The Ukrainian goal has always been to create a propaganda exercise, to demonize the Russians, and to do what they couldn't do otherwise. The Ukrainians have been calling for a ceasefire in the, you know, in the area, and the, you know, ceasefire all along the front line, which Russians won't do. The Russians say, you're not getting a ceasefire without a comprehensive peace plan. There is no comprehensive peace plan because Zelensky doesn't want a peace plan. But a ceasefire buys time for the Ukrainians to, you know, arrest their troops, rotate their troops, re-equip their troops, etc. So they're trying to create conditions for ceasefires. Eleshky is a ceasefire-generating operation. It's supposed to be the initial example, you know, sort of the precedent that would be set for additional things. And you hear it today, even when Eleshky is done, now the Ukrainians are saying, this is something we seek to repeat over and over and over again, because this was a good deal for them. You notice that the Russians are downplaying issues like how many people were evacuated, who went to Ukraine, who went to Russia. Why?
Because the Russians aren't seeking to politicize a humanitarian relief operation. Their objective was to bring assistance to the people that needed assistance, regardless of where their loyalties were. And Yana Lantratova deserves a tremendous amount of credit for this. So does her counterpart, Dmitry Lubinitz. He's the Ukrainian ombudsman for human rights. And, you know, I think they both developed a good reputation over time. But the difference is that he has gone back. And instead of promoting humanitarianism, he's promoting pro-Ukrainian propaganda. And he's allowing, you know, the events to be shifted in a way that, you know, accuses the Russians of nefarious activity. For instance, one of the big things taking place today is that the Russians used the humanitarian relief operation to reinforce their positions, to rotate their positions. And the evidence brought forward is videoed from Sky News, a British outlet, which is very anti-Russian, saying, this is what we filmed during this.
But, you know, Dmitry Lubinitz came out and said, now, you see, we actually coordinated this with the Russians. And these vehicles were painted with red crosses. They are involved in demining operations. We monitored this activity closely. Once they finished their demining work, they returned to their original posture. So they're lying. The Ukrainians lie. The pro-Ukrainian media lies. They spin this in, you know, a dozen different ways. But what they're not doing is telling the truth. If they were telling the truth, they would admit up front that Aleszky was a Ukrainian propaganda exercise from day one, that the humanitarian disaster that existed in Aleszky, no one's denying this, was perpetrated by the Ukrainians. It was Ukrainian drones that isolated the city, denied food from being brought in. It was Ukrainian drones that terrorized the civilian population. It was Ukrainian artillery that did the same thing.
Whenever the Russians tried to send in humanitarian relief, the Ukrainians attacked them. The Russians simply did not attack Aleszky because Aleszky belongs to Russia. But this is the myth-making that's taking place. And it's important that, you know, we understand this because this Aleszky precedent is something that people are going to be promoting going forward. Melania Trump has attached her name to this effort. You know, she did provide political, you know, cover overhead. But the hard, the heavy lifting was done by Yana Latratova and Dmitry Lubinitz. These two people deserve all the credit in the world. Indeed, you know, in this day and age when we're looking for heroes, when we're looking for people to label peacemakers and, you know, peacekeepers, people promoting peace, these people may be deservant of a Nobel Peace Prize, these two names should be front and center. Yana Latratova of the Russian Federation, Dmitry Lubinitz of the Ukraine, of Ukraine. These are people who work hard. The Russian government, I believe, is very sincere in promoting, you know, genuine humanitarianism. Dmitry, I believe, is likewise. But his government, as we've seen, is not serious about humanitarian intervention. They're serious about creating a humanitarian crisis and using that to promote an anti-Russian agenda.
But this doesn't detract from the hard work that Dmitry Lubinitz did together with Yana Latratova. So when we think about the Nobel Peace Prize, when we think about people deservant of this, I would, you know, suggest that people start talking about these two people. Yana Latratova, Dmitry Lubinitz, these should be the future Nobel Peace Prize winners for what they did in Eleszky and hopefully what they can do down the road in, you know, alleviating the humanitarian consequences of war. Anyways, this is my rant. The next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. The next time a thought crosses my mind, I'll be sure to let you know. Thank you.